We Analyzed the SAVE Plan on Reddit: Here Is a Simple Explanation

The new "Saving on a Valuable Education" (SAVE) plan for federal student loans has been a hot topic on Reddit communities like r/StudentLoans. It's being called the most generous repayment plan ever created, but the details can be confusing. To cut through the noise, we analyzed hundreds of posts and comments from real borrowers on Reddit to provide a simple, clear explanation of how the SAVE plan actually works and what it means for you.

Problem: The Official Rules are Complicated

The government's official websites, while accurate, are filled with dense, technical language. Borrowers are left with pressing questions: Is SAVE really better than the old plans? How is the payment calculated? What's this about an interest subsidy? Will my loans actually be forgiven? People are turning to Reddit to get answers from their peers who are navigating the system in real-time.

Solution: A Simple Breakdown Based on Real Borrower Experiences

By synthesizing the collective knowledge of the Reddit community, we can explain the SAVE plan in a way that focuses on what matters most to borrowers. Here are the three game-changing features of the SAVE plan that Redditors are talking about most.

1. A Lower Monthly Payment

How it works: Your monthly payment is based on your "discretionary income." SAVE calculates this differently and more generously than older plans.

The Old Way (e.g., REPAYE plan): Discretionary income was your total income minus 150% of the poverty line for your family size. Your payment was 10% of that number.
The New SAVE Way: Discretionary income is your total income minus 225% of the poverty line. Your payment is 10% of that number (and will drop to just 5% for undergraduate loans in July 2024).

What this means in plain English: The amount of your income that is protected from being used in the payment calculation is much larger. This results in a significantly lower monthly payment for most people.

"My payment went from $350 on REPAYE to $68 on SAVE. It's a huge relief and lets me actually save some money for the first time." - A common sentiment on r/StudentLoans

2. The Interest Subsidy: No More Negative Amortization

How it works: This is the most powerful and popular feature of the SAVE plan. If your calculated monthly payment is not enough to cover the interest that accrues that month, the government waives the remaining interest.

What this means in plain English: Your loan balance will NEVER grow as long as you make your required monthly payment. This is a massive change from old plans, where borrowers would make payments for years only to see their total loan balance increase due to unpaid interest.

"The interest subsidy is the real MVP. My payment is $0, and I know my $100k loan balance isn't going to balloon to $150k while I'm on this plan. My balance will not go up." - A frequent comment from high-balance, low-income borrowers.

3. A Shorter Path to Forgiveness for Smaller Loans

How it works: The old plans required 20 or 25 years of payments before any remaining balance was forgiven (and taxed). The SAVE plan introduces a new, faster timeline for borrowers with smaller original loan balances.

If your original principal balance for all your loans was $12,000 or less , any remaining balance will be forgiven after you make just 10 years of payments (120 payments).
For every $1,000 borrowed above $12,000, one additional year of payments is required before forgiveness. For example, an original balance of $14,000 would be forgiven after 12 years. The maximum time to forgiveness is capped at 20 or 25 years, depending on whether you have graduate loans.

What this means in plain English: This is a huge benefit for people who attended community college or only took out small loans for their undergraduate degree. It provides a much faster, more attainable end date for their student debt.

Who is the SAVE Plan For?

Based on discussions on Reddit, the SAVE plan is overwhelmingly beneficial for:

Low-to-Middle Income Earners: Especially those whose income is not significantly higher than their loan balance. The generous discretionary income calculation and interest subsidy provide immediate and substantial relief.
Borrowers with High Loan Balances: For those with six-figure debt (like veterinarians, dentists, etc.), the interest subsidy is a financial lifeline that prevents their debt from spiraling out of control.
Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) Candidates: If you work for a qualifying non-profit or government employer, the SAVE plan is a perfect fit. It gives you the lowest possible monthly payment, and any remaining balance will be forgiven, tax-free, after 120 qualifying payments.

Who Might NOT Benefit as Much?

High-Income Earners with Low Debt: If you have a very high income relative to your loan balance, your payment on SAVE might be higher than on the standard 10-year plan. In this case, your goal should be to pay the loan off as aggressively as possible.

Conclusion: A Game-Changer for Most Borrowers

The consensus on Reddit is clear: the SAVE plan is a revolutionary step forward in student loan repayment. By providing lower monthly payments, and most importantly, by stopping loan balances from growing due to unpaid interest, it offers a manageable and predictable path forward. If you have federal student loans, the advice from the community is unanimous: log into StudentAid.gov, use the official loan simulator, and see how much the SAVE plan could help you.

Community Discussion

Have questions or insights about this guide? Join the conversation below using your GitHub account.