The Definitive Guide to the Most Profitable Items to Sell Locally (2025)
Local marketplaces like OfferUp and Facebook Marketplace are bustling platforms perfect for decluttering your home and making extra cash. But what items actually sell the best and offer the most profit? To find out, we analyzed sales data and trending searches from the past year. This guide reveals the top 10 most profitable items to sell, helping you maximize your earnings in 2025.
On This Page:
The Key to Success: A Great Listing Sells Itself
Before you list anything, take 15 minutes to clean the item thoroughly and take good photos. A clean, well-lit item in a clutter-free space looks more valuable and trustworthy. Write a descriptive title (include brand, model, and size) and an honest description. This simple effort is the single best way to get a higher price and a faster sale, regardless of the platform you choose.
The Methodology: What Makes an Item "Profitable"?
Our analysis didn't just look at high-ticket items. We defined "profitable" based on a combination of three factors:
- High Demand: How many buyers are actively searching for the item?
- Fast Sale Speed: How quickly does the item sell after being listed?
- Good Resale Value: How much of its original value does the item retain?
The Top 10 Most Profitable Items to Sell Locally
Furniture (Small & Easy-to-Move)
Furniture is consistently the number one category. The most profitable items are smaller pieces that fit in a car or SUV. Think coffee tables, nightstands, bookshelves, and office chairs. These are in high demand from apartment dwellers and college students.
Electronics (Recent Models)
Smartphones, tablets, laptops, and gaming consoles are always hot sellers, but they must be recent models (last 2-4 years). An iPhone 12 will sell in hours; an iPhone 6 will sit for weeks. Including the original box can add 10-20% to your price.
Video Games and Consoles
Nintendo products, especially the Switch and its top games (Mario Kart, Zelda), hold their value incredibly well. Retro gaming is also a huge market; old consoles like the N64 or GameCube are highly sought after.
Lego Sets
Lego is like gold on the second-hand market. Used sets from popular themes like Star Wars or Harry Potter can sell for 70-80% of their original price. Selling them by the pound in bulk is also very profitable.
Home Fitness Equipment
Demand for home gym gear remains high. Adjustable dumbbells, weight benches, kettlebells, and resistance bands are extremely popular. They are expensive to ship new, making local pickup on a marketplace a preferred option for buyers.
Tools and Home Improvement Gear
Power tools from reputable brands like DeWalt, Milwaukee, and Ryobi are always in demand. Ladders, tool chests, and lawn equipment also sell very quickly, especially in the spring and summer.
Bicycles
Adult bicycles from well-known brands like Trek, Specialized, and Giant retain their value well. Kids' bikes are also a quick sell, as parents are always looking for a good deal on the next size up.
Kitchen Appliances (Countertop)
High-end countertop appliances are very profitable. Think KitchenAid stand mixers, Vitamix blenders, air fryers, and espresso machines. Buyers are always looking for a deal on a lightly used model.
Baby and Kids' Gear
Parents are always looking to save money on items their children will quickly outgrow. Strollers (especially jogging or double strollers), high chairs, and large play sets from brands like UPPAbaby and Graco are top sellers.
Musical Instruments
Beginner-level acoustic guitars, electric keyboards, and drum sets are fantastic sellers. Many people want to pick up a new hobby but are hesitant to pay full price for a new instrument.
Next Steps: Choosing a Platform and Selling Safely
Now that you know what to sell, you need to decide where to list it and how to protect yourself during the transaction.
Which Platform is Best for Sellers?
Both OfferUp and Facebook Marketplace are excellent, free options for local sales. However, they have key differences in audience size, fees for shipping, and user anonymity. We've done a complete data-driven analysis to help you choose. Read our guide: OfferUp vs. Facebook Marketplace: Which is Better for Sellers?
How to Avoid Getting Scammed
Unfortunately, scammers are active on all online marketplaces. They often use fake payment emails or verification code tricks to steal your items or information. Your best defense is to be informed. Before you list your first item, you must read our guide on the most common scams targeting sellers and how to avoid them .
Conclusion: Sell What People Need (and What's Hard to Ship)
The data shows a clear trend: the most profitable items to sell locally are practical things that people need for their homes and hobbies. The common thread is that many of these items are large, heavy, or inconvenient to ship, making the local pickup model of marketplaces the perfect venue. By focusing your selling efforts on these top 10 categories, you can clear out your clutter and ensure you're getting the best possible return for your items in 2025.
Community Discussion
Have questions or insights about this guide? Join the conversation below using your GitHub account.